Fragrance Throwdown: Givenchy Organza Indécence versus Anné Pliska eau de parfum

 

Photo of wrestlers via Wikimedia Commons

Today’s Full Review Friday post is another Fragrance Throwdown.  I’m glad to see these wrestler guys again – I had missed them!

I had owned a small bottle of Organza Indécence for three years or so and enjoyed it before smelling Anné Pliska. AP seemed to me to be a darker, thicker rendition of Organza Indécence – OI on steroids, if you will – and I thought it would be interesting to test them wrist-to-wrist.

Organza Indecence (original packaging) from Fragrantica

Notes for Organza Indécence, from Fragrantica: Cinnamon, tangerine, jacaranda wood, plum, patchouli, amber, vanilla. With all those weighty notes, you’d think this would be a heavy oriental behemoth, a 400-pound gorilla plopping himself on your couch with a bag of chips and the TV remote, but it isn’t. Instead, OI is warm but lightweight, a nice slubby silk sweater that has texture and warmth but doesn’t smother. I never seem to notice the plum, and I can’t pick out jacaranda as opposed to other wood. I do also pick up on a few notes that aren’t listed; perhaps I’m imagining them, but possibly they’re there in smaller quantities; I think I smell a bit of rose, and I’m almost certain that there’s cedar in the base as well as a light touch of skin-type musk.

OI lasts on my skin for about 4-6 hours, depending on how heavily it’s applied – that’s quite good lasting power for me. It’s a very comfortable fragrance.

I have tested both the original version in its Bene Gesserit headdress bottle (as someone on Perfume Posse put it) and the Les Parfums Mythiques version. To me, there are very few differences, and although I’ve read several comments that the new version is too vanillic, not as deep, I’m wondering if the aging of this woody oriental fragrance has exaggerated the differences. Base notes tend to age pretty well, often getting deeper and more nuanced, especially compared to top notes like citrus, which rarely survives the passing of years. The original seems to be a little more woody and ambery, and compared to the new, I start wondering if there might be some benzoin in it – its sweet base notes are deeper and slightly less edible than the new scent’s. The Mythiques version has a brighter citrus (or is that because it’s new?), and its vanilla is creamy and sweet, though it’s still not a Creamsicle-esque edible delight. There are still plenty of woods in there. I myself prefer the new version for its sunnier disposition, though if you especially love the basenotes of original OI you might be slightly disappointed. It’s by no means a shadow of its former self, but it is a little lighter; to my mind, the increased sunniness of the new keeps it just as warm as the old.

 

Anne Pliska parfum, from Fragrantica. I don't get why the packaging uses this color pink; it smells more like an orangey sunset pink to me.

I first tried Anné Pliska a few weeks ago, from a sample of eau de parfum, and from the beginning, it reminded me of Organza Indécence: the orange, the spice, the vanilla-patchouli. But AP is OI on steroids – bigger, heavier, warmer, louder, more persistent. The notes for Anné Pliska, also from Fragrantica: Orange, bergamot, geranium, patchouli, amber, vanilla, musk.

AP starts out with a gorgeous orange note, round and full and concentrated, bittersweet like marmalade. There’s also a spicy note, but I can’t identify which spice.  It may be a mixture, but all I can say for certain is that it doesn’t seem to be clove. Very quickly it moves into a rich, labdanum-heavy thing, warm as a wool sweater, with a chewy texture that makes me think nervously about my teeth. AP is not noticeably floral but I do register the aromatic geranium note. It’s not what I’d call a complex fragrance, but it is rich and full and solid. It does go through about half an hour when I largely smell heliotrope, and it is truly a big orangey-pink 400-pound Play-Doh gorilla camped out on my couch with the remote. I like it a lot better when the heliotrope finally goes away (or gets trumped by the amber). The patchouli is quite noticeable to me though not offensively so. AP lasts for a long time, about 6-8 hours on me, and radiates from clothing for at least a week or so. I have not tried the parfum; I’ve heard that it is even richer and smoother than the edp.

From the beginning, these two smell like variations on a theme. OI is a little spicier and its citrus note lighter, while AP’s orange is thick like candied peel. I’d call OI a woody-vanilla fragrance, and AP is really a labdanum-amber fragrance decorated with that lovely orange topnote. OI is lighter overall, and does well in warm fall weather, though it would seem out of place to me in spring and summer. I can’t imagine wearing AP in any weather other than winter, it’s such a warm blanket of a smell.

I’ve recently had an epiphany, as well: I’ve come to realize that a certain quality of labdanum – the linseed putty/old rubberized tarpaulin bit, not the sweet rich amber bit – really, really bothers me; it’s that aspect of labdanum that puts me off Youth Dew and Opium. That’s what it is – it’s not opoponax or tolu balsam, it’s labdanum, either in heavy concentration or a certain grade of raw material. I’m learning to be careful with fragrances that list notes of either amber or labdanum, because they may or may not contain that “ghost of Youth Dew” thing that I hate so much. Quite a few fragrances that purport to contain labdanum, I do like. I’m not sure what the difference is between the ones I like and the ones I can’t stand, or how to identify the offensive element other than trying it on skin.

Anné Pliska is a good fragrance – solid, well-crafted, with a strong identity. But I declare Organza Indécence the winner of the Throwdown, at least for me. Organza Indécence is more versatile, and in my opinion, more interesting. Out of curiosity, I tossed out a poll to my Facebook perfume friends, asking whether they preferred OI, AP, both, or neither. The results: 6 votes for OI, 4 votes for AP, two for both and one for neither. What do you say?

Share

22 thoughts on “Fragrance Throwdown: Givenchy Organza Indécence versus Anné Pliska eau de parfum”

  1. I can’t add to the poll as I haven’t tried AP, but I do love OI. And knowing my tastes, I am pretty sure I would prefer the OI as I generally prefer lighter scents. I have the old dress bottle and have sniffed the new version, but haven’t really tried them side by side – I like citrus, so I may prefer thenew one as well.

    Interesting point about the aging of vintage perfumes – had never thought that it could be the vintage perfume responsible for the difference in smell when comparing to newer versions.

    1. OI is definitely lighter, and, I think, easier to wear.

      I think that the basenotes get a little deeper as fragrances age, and if you’ve got a scent that’s got a larger proportion of basenotes, a new bottle will seem at least a little bit thinner even with no reformulation. I *could* be full of it, but that’s my guess, anyway.

  2. I don’t know Anne Pliska too well (having smelled it only once) but the beginning of champagne de bois reminded me of Organza Indecence..do you get that at all?

    1. Huh… CdB and OI… well, I do know that the aldehydes in CdB have a citrus angle. Orange, sweetness, wood – it’s not totally out of the question, though I don’t think I’d have connected them in my mind.

  3. I haven’t tried either of these, but you make Indecence sound so lovely that I feel compelled to try it. I was never a big fan of the original Organza.

    1. Oh, try it if you get a chance! It’s not much like Organza, which I have a mini bottle of and which strikes me as being much sweeter and much simpler (white florals, vanilla).

  4. OI is one of my favorites. It is one of a handful of perfumes I have used a full bottle of and have two backups (original formulation)! I believe I tried the Anne Pliska a few years ago when I started my online sample shopping and something in it did not work for me (scent headache).

    Interesting that you smell rose in the OI. If I remember correctly Givenchy claimed it was a perfume with no flowers in it.

    1. OI is so nice! I have a hard time with the play-doh heliotrope in AP myself.

      I wasn’t into perfume when OI was released, and I don’t remember seeing that “no-flowers” claim. Of course, that could be PR guff – or I might be hallucinating, that’s always possible… Do you smell cedar in it?

  5. Mals- Cedar? My sinuses are so bad and I am not good at this note thing AT ALL. I just smell cinnamon, vanilla,and a nice incense/wood thing which must be the patchouli and wood combo. Wore it to bed last night about 1am (work afternoon shift). Still in my pajamas at 11:40 am(MLK day no school yay!) and can still smell the sweet vanilla woody smell I love so much!

    P.S. No Mary Greenwell Plum for me. I get migraines-not so much now that I’m older but certain scents I really can’t do. Plum gave me a headache so it’s a no go!

    1. The cedar isn’t a focus, but yeah, I’m pretty sure it’s there under the patchouli-vanilla thing.

      Re Plum: so sorry! Not everything works for everybody…

  6. I haven’t smelled either, but serendipitously, both were on my TPC wishlist, slated for a February order…. or maybe March, I’ve been holding off on my SSS order because I’ve wanted to sample Nostalgie as well as To Dream and Fig Tree.

    I actually had no idea OI and Anne Pliska were similar when I added them, I just know I’ve been craving comfort scents lately (no big surprise, it’s minus 30 around here right now). One question I have though: I was under the impression OI wasn’t as easy to find these days. That alone might sway me in Anne Pliska’s direction, especially since The Perfume Shoppe sells it, and I wouldn’t have to deal with customs.

    1. Oh, it is fun to see if you get the same out of something as another reviewer! (If you can’t find OI, PM me. I has some.)

  7. I was so glad to see the wrestlers as I scrolled down, catching up on the new site! Throwdowns are tops 😉

    Anne Pliska is a favorite of mine– to me, it smells of a creamsicle version of Shalimar! Must be the labdanum… I haven’t smelled OI, though it’s been on my “to sniff” list forever. I’m glad to hear that the new version is still good, even if it has been tweaked a little.

    1. I love those wrestler guys! And throwdowns are fun.

      You should get a nose on some OI if you can find it – it’s good. Might be a little lighter than your usual fare, but worth wearing.

  8. Organza Indecence smells like a yummy Macaroon cookie, sweet, vanilla and coconuty. After I used up my first unique bottle, I went for more…I bought what I thought was Organza Indecence because of the look alike bottle. Disappointed, What I ended up buying was just Organza. Yuck shock to my senses.
    Beware of what you buy because these bottles are confusing, make sure your buying what you want and smell it first.

  9. Anne Pliska does if for me, powdery combo of amber and orange with a hint of musk, georgeous scent, a true classic..Now found cheaper then anyone else at Thefragrancefactory.com

    1. The Anne Pliska is very pretty! Glad you like it.

      (I approved this comment because your email address seems a personal one, not affiliated with the website you mentioned.)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *